Limits or Zones?

Press Releases: 27th June 2010 - 20's Plenty For Us welcomes government moves towards 20 mph limit - 28th Sept 2009 - 20’s Plenty for Us calls for clarity from DfT on lower residential speed limits        18th April 2009 - 20’s Plenty For Us welcomes expected 20’s Plenty For UK           7th April 09 - 20's Plenty Success in York    29th October 08 - 20’s Plenty For Us welcomes Transport Committee support for increased use of 20 mph limits         19th October 08 - 20’s Plenty For Us now reaches ¾ million residents    17th Sep - 20's Plenty For Us to co-host National Conference        22nd June - 20's Plenty by 2010 campaign launched     31st May - 20's Plenty For Us submits evidence to Transport Commitee    18th May - Government support for 20 mph welcomed but flawed.    23rd Feb 08    Norwich - Another City chooses 20 mph for residential roads.       28th Jan 08 AA spreads misleading information on 20 mph and CO2 emissions.     24th Jan - 20's Plenty For Us welcomes London's proposed 20 mph default

Home
Up

 

From a legal point of view 20 mph Speed Zones are exactly the same as 20 mph Limits with regard to the speed you are allowed to drive at. Both have a maximum speed of 20 mph. Note that these are different from Home Zones which may have design speeds much lower than 20 mph.

The primary difference between "zones" and "limits" is one of engineering and the requirements for additional signing, etc.

20 Mph Zones

20 mph zones require that no point in the "zone" is further than 50m from a traffic calming feature, unless the road is a cul-de-sac of less than 80m in length.

A 20 mph zone is indicated by special 20 mph zone entry and exit signs.

No additional speed limit signs are used within a 20 mph zone because the traffic calming methods should mean that vehicle speeds are low enough for the signs to be unnecessary 

20 mph Limits

20 mph limits are indicated by terminal speed limit signs and repeater signs (usually small signs on lamp posts) at regular intervals.

20 mph limits usually do not have any traffic calming features. However these can be added if required.

Traffic Calming

In the UK context this is often misinterpreted as meaning physical speed constraints such as speed bumps and speed tables (vertical) or chicanes, road narrowing and build outs (horizontal). In fact it can also include gateways, road markings, hatching, carriageway roundels and rumble devices.

Note that in the EU context Traffic Calming is used as a term for "reducing vehicle speeds" rather than referring to the implementation of any engineering measures. Hence when a European traffic engineer refers to their "traffic calming" as a measure for increasing vulnerable road user safety they merely mean that they have taken steps to reduce speeds, including speed limit enforcement.

20's Plenty For Us promotes the use of community wide default 20 mph speed limits in residential areas. These should be implemented without any form of traffic calming which should only be retrospectively introduced where it is found to be necessary. Arterial and main roads should be set by the local authority with reference to the local conditions.

Type of Speed Reduction Advantages Disadvantages
20 mph Zones
  • Constrains motor vehicle speeds by physical or physiological measures thereby enhancing conformity.
  • Physical measures are uncomfortable even for motor vehicles conforming to speed limits.
  • Slows down emergency service vehicles
  • Expensive to implement
  • Expensive to maintain and re-surface
  • Can cause noise and vibration
  • Can result in acceleration between features by drivers seeking to maximise average speed, thereby increasing pollution and emissions.
20 mph Limits
  • Cheap to implement. For Portsmouth the total cost of an authority with 187,000 residents for just £475,000. Equivalent to to the cost of 2 junctions with traffic lights.
  • Little resident opposition.
  • Encourages community wide debate when put in across an authority which increases conformity.
  • Requires commitment from Councillors, Council Officers and Community to deliver lower speeds.

 
  • Nothing to stop drivers exceeding limit other than responsibility, other limit-conforming drivers and enforcement.
  • Requires commitment from Councillors, Council Officers and Community to deliver lower speeds.

       

For further details email rodk@20splentyforus.org.uk or call Rod King on 07973 639781 or Chris Mayes on 0151 706 4464